Welcome to our Site for MG, Triumph and Austin-Healey Car Information.
MG MGB Technical - 72B Convertible Top Fit ???
| Now that winter requires that I limit myself to simply staring at my 72B parked in the garage, I've started to notice things. I'll admit I haven't driven it much with the top up in my 7 months of ownership, but thought unfolding it from behind the seat during winter would be a good idea. So now I've been staring at it I've notice something odd about how the top fits and I don't have access to another 72B to see what is wrong. The top is properly clamped onto the top of the windshield. The support frame is aligned properly, as far as I can tell (the cross bars line up with thicker areas of top). And the back is attach to the clips. Windows appear properly tight, not real tight as car appears to be missing a couple of fasteners. However, with the side windows rolled all the way up (right to flush with the side window vent frames), the windows do not reach the point of sliding in between the inner and outer seal area of the convertible top. It does go up high enough to overlap the inside longer flap, but it is an inch or more short of going behind the outer shorter flap. How do I determine if this is actually the right top on the car? If anyone has a photo of just how the top should look from the side and how the window slips inbetween the two flaps I'd appreciate seeing them. Or if anyone would like to see a photo of what I'm trying to explain please contact me. Thanks BobA Stillwater, MN robtwander1@juno.com robert.anderson@state.mn.us |
| R.W Anderson |
| Bob, I've got a brand-new aftermarket top (Moss or VB, don't remember which) and the fit is exactly as you describe ('73 B). The outer, shorter seal is supposed to be part of the rain channel. The inner seal keeps out the wind and gives heavy rain some place to go (your lap). ;) You don't say, but I presume the window just barely clears the inner seal/flap also? What you're describing is common to a lot if not all of the aftermarket tops. R. |
| Rick Stevens |
| Bob That sounds about right. Don't forget that the rain channel that Rick refers to starts at a point level with the windscreen surrround which is slightly higher than the top of the quarterlight and slightly higher still than the top of the dropglass. This means that there is going to be a gap of about 1" between the top of the dropglass and the rain channel. I've emailled you a picture of my MGC showing, hopefully, the same situation you find yourself in. Robert |
| R Lynex |
| I've seen some expensive replacement tops just like that. The width of the material is so insufficient that the gutter arches above the top of the drop glass, and the flap of material that is supposed to hand down and be flush with the glass is bowed in, so much so that you could get a slim hand in there without touching the sides. Wind and rain will blow right in. The bottom of the gutter *should* just run along the top of the glass. Mine came with a bottom of the range flimsy vinyl number which I did think I would replace with something a bit more plush - until I saw the fit of some of these. Some manufacturers/supplier may well have properly fitting tops, but I don't want to find out the expensive way which don't. |
| Paul Hunt 2 |
| Bob Have a look in Anders Ditlev Clausagers book 'Original MGB With MGC and MGB GT V8', it is widely recognised as the 'Bible' for that series. (Buy yourself a copy - you won't regret it!) There are several pictures of hoods fitted to different Model Years with different Hood Frames (Packaway, Folding and Michelotti) under the Weather Equipment section from Page 53. In each case the gap is around 1". One picture shows the gutter 'arching' as Paul said but I suggest that is to do with the hood frame and not the hood material. Robert |
| R Lynex |
| I've not liked to comment on or question those with poor fitting hoods. I've never known whether it was a mis-match between frame and top material, or simply that the top was manufactured using a bad jig. Apart from being the wrong frame for the car I'd be more inclined to suspect a bad jig than some problem with the frame, especially if the old top was a significantly better fit on the same frame. |
| Paul Hunt 2 |
| It might also be the incorrect top for the top frame on the car, which might not be original. FWIW Larry |
| Larry Hallanger |
| Anyone have a contact with a top maker who might see this as a chance to capture the market? I've never seen one that did seal well and all it would take is to widen that strip some to make them all fit and seal better, or so it seams. Jim |
| Jim Blackwood |
| Most tops are fitted incorrectly. The longitudinal seams should line up with the joins in the windscreen frame, and the edge seam should be just below the header bar outer front corner. If this is done, the door glass will just clear the outer gutter, and be about 1" above the inner flap. It is not easy to get this fit; I usually fit tops on a warm day, and attach several small clamps with padding to the top front corners, then use rubber tarp straps down to the rocker lower edge and to the front wheels. After a couple of hours in the sun, the top will stretch to the point that you can attach it to the header in the correct position. I've even done this on tops that had been on the car for several years, all the while pissing on the owners. It is also very common for the top frames to be distorted in many directions, so I take time to get the correct curves and lineup on that first. FRM |
| FR Millmore |
| Slightly off topic I have a factory hardtop that I have had a multitude of early Bs 64,65,67 and it presently sits on a 1969 MGC a nice fit on all of them. Enter a 1976 B that I redid to include a soft top from Prestige which fit perfectly.SOooo, I thought, "I'll put the hardtop on for the cold season" Well on it went, the rear mounts slid under the clips,the side mounts lined up fine and the windshield clamps sealed the leading edge as tight as a drum, slideing behind the wheel I rolled up the windows they were about one inch short of the seal in the hardtop although they fit inside the flaps of the softtop as nice as any I've seen. Any thoughts? RIC |
| Ric Lloyd |
| Ric- The glass should come pretty well level with the top of the vent frames, which in turn should be about 1/4" above the rearmost corner of the windscreen frame; that's the reference point. If all that seems correct, it's difficult to see how the hardtop wouldn't fit. To expand on the top frame issue, the bows get bent from people jamming the top down with material between the bows. This bends the center of the bows "down", which is generally in two planes relative to the bow axis & curve. I see lots of cars with the erect frame flat to concave, whereas it should have a pronounced convex upward curve matching the windscreen frame. This in turn causes the downward curved outer bow ends to rise and go out sideways, giving the really bad window fit. It is impossible to get a correct fit of the top fabric until the bows are correct. Life is also easier if you store the car with the top up, and DON'T pile stuff on the top! Top material shrinks over time, especially in the box - it can really be fun installing one that was bought ten years earlier! I have had the experience of installing two identical tops, bought at the same time, one immediately and one years later - time is the factor. FRM |
| FR Millmore |
| Whilst getting the longditudinal seams off-line *will* result in poor fit, it will be because one gutter is above where it should be and the other below. There are still plenty of tops out there that have the gutters too high on *both* sides, i.e. insufficient material width. |
| Paul Hunt 2 |
| Paul- While there appear to be some tops with insufficient material width, I have found these to be either very old stock or very cheap tops, the latter not so much a problem as it used to be when there was a lot of low price competition. I am not talking about tops that are installed off center, but about those where the material is not stretched correctly at the header rail, prior to being fastened to same. This results in both seams being inboard of the windscreen joins. The front end of the edge seam has a pronounced S curve in it. In the correct position, this will neatly follow the corner of the header, and will locate the gutter edge correctly relative to the screen. The outer gutter will be about 1/4" above the vent window frame. If all that is correct, the outer gutter should be straight back and parallel to the door glass; there should be no arch or curve in this line. If it is not, then the problem is the top frame. In ref. to Bob's original post, the door glass does not go up behind the outer gutter - "slip behind the flap" - since if it did, you could not open or close the door with the window up. Bob, if you contact me, I will tell you how to send me pictures, from which I can likely tell you exactly why your top doesn't fit. FRM |
| FR Millmore |
| Does anyone still make a well fiting top? When the rain came at the MG2006 car show, I saw a whole lot of ill-fitting tops. Most of them had the poor rain gutter fit around the window. |
| Carl Floyd |
| I had a look at mine and the fit is just fine. Bear in mind that the door has to open with the window up. If the glass goes too high past the edge of the flap it just won't work. My top is old, and one of the cheapest ones made but it fits. It has shrunk a bit so it can be challenging to latch however. I would tend to agree that the amount of bow in the bows would be a big factor in determining fit. Jim |
| Jim Blackwood |
| Carl - no doubt expensive ones. I've seen the same thing in the UK, gaping spaces above the windows you could get a hand in. My bottom-of-the range thin vinyl has the gutters sitting just at the top of the windows both sides, and the inside flap lying straight and flat against the glass. That is how they are *all* supposed to be. |
| Paul Hunt 2 |
| Very depressing to take the time to carefully explain it all and have even those I have come to respect for knowledge and thought not get it. Is this a reading problem, a belief problem, a total failure to think about it and look at the damn car? Or am I on the wrong planet? ***It ain't the top, it's the installation!*** In the last few years I have installed Robbins, AMCO, and whatever UK made top comes from LBC. I have also refitted several unknown tops that were ill fitting. All these cars had the problems described. After I straightened the top frames - every one bent to some degree when I removed the old top - every one fit from acceptable to perfect, The differences were in how badly they were bent to start, and how much time I could afford to spend within the customer's parameters (and my own increasing reluctance to donate work I should get paid for - which is starting to apply to advice). Apparent poor fit is also sometimes due to owners who are too lazy to fasten all the auxiliary snaps that keep the top correct; if ignored all the time, eventually the top stretches out of shape. This is also v annoying when you have taken the time to make it all correct. Sometimes door and windscreen/doorglass alignment are wrong, which can lead to lots of hours, but it is not right to blame the top in these cases. There are certainly lots of crappy parts out there, but, in the end, fitting and most functional problems are the responsibility of the mechanic, be it tops, engines, electrics, or anything else. At this point, failure of anybody to understand this issue is the reader's fault. If there's anything I have not made clear, ask. FRM |
| FR Millmore |
| So in other words: If you bought a lousy Chinese made part and it doesn't fit, it's your own damn fault. Well - that covers that. I guess now we can just go ahead and close this board, since any further questions are unnecessary. PS - Don't anybody here bother going through any green lights at intersections. When that bloke running the red light t-bones you, it's gonna be your fault. R. |
| Rick Stevens |
| Well now Rick, isn't that a bit harsh? After all, I think FR has something there with the frame distortion and all. I know I've fitted less than a half dozen tops and had pretty acceptable results but I sure don't claim to be an expert on it, and if FR's fitted every kind of top made and says they can all be made to fit correctly I for one would tend to buy it. After all, my tops have been the cheapest available. Jim |
| Jim Blackwood |
| Here's the deal: The youngest of these cars is 27 years old. Lots of things have happened in the intervening years, from accidents to previous owners to simple sagging from age. Many of them have had tops, mounting hardware and windshields removed and replaced numerous times. On top of that, many (!!!) aftermarket products are simply crap. Yes, there are cases where the current owner is simply incompetent when it comes to properly fitting a top. But for anybody to sit here and pass judgment on every single ill-fitting top as being the owner's fault is nonsense. Does everybody on this board have year after year after year of fitting top after top after top? Of course not. We come here seeking advice, not scorn. Most of us. If someone has advice, give it. That's why most of come here: to ask questions and to learn. If someone disagrees with somebody else's advice, say so and give reasons for that disagreement - preferably offering a viable alternative answer in the process. Don't blame people for being victims of others' failures and do NOT heap scorn on those who don't follow a particular piece of advice. No, my comments weren't harsh. R. |
| Rick Stevens |
| If the old top fitted poorly, and the new top fits poorly, then yes it could be the frame, installation or both tops. But if the old top fitted fine and the new one is rubbish then I don't see how it can be the frame. And if the problem is gaping holes above *both* side windows which seems to be the common problem I don't really see how it can be installation, the force needed to pull the centre too far forwards such that it pulls the sides in doesn't bear thinking about. I really don't understand why FRM can't accept that poor manufacture isn't possible, and in fact quite likely given where so many parts are manufactured these days. |
| Paul Hunt 2 |
| I'm with Rick & Paul. There are many, many ill-fitting tops. No way can they all be dismissed as poor installations. My Dad bought his '63 B brand new. He has always installed his own tops with good results. Now no one seems to make a top that he can get to fit. Moss said he had some kind of grey frame missing link. He sent them his old Amco top (which they said the would return, but never have). They sent him a new top & payed to have an upholstery shop (that have done many Bs) install it. Guess what? It still does not fit right aroung the windows. The manufactures have forgotten how to make the different variations. My Dad was sent one top where the v-notches in the back were wrong. He was told that they were all like that & there had been no complaints. I am not aware of any changes (from 62-80) in the spacing of the retainers that hold the back of the top snug to the body. |
| Carl Floyd |
Friends, (and the rest of you too) After much thought I have decided to beat this horse some more. The point is NOT to aggravate anyone, but to solve the problem. I am NOT a top "expert", i.e., it is not my main business; I am a "Mechanic", and as such my job is to figure out how things work, and why they don't, and then to fix it. Can't help you with actually doing the work, unless you drive your car over here, when I will be glad to correct it or tell you precisely why it won't work, but the rest is covered - please read carefully and think. That applies to communication as well as tops, engines, etc; if I fail, I ask that you contribute useful criticism, not defensive BS.. All is based on my experience, which is likely more extensive than most of yours, and certainly more authoritative if you can't get a top to fit. Following is more or less the procedure I use to solve all problems, When I do stupid things, I call myself way worse than I will call anyone here. It all will pass eventually. I suggest you print it out so you can compare directly with the original posts referenced. Point by point: RWA, 17 Jan You asked a question, and several folks answered, including me. You have not reappeared, commented, or contributed; and, you have not bothered to take me up on my invitation to solve your question, your problem. The offer is still open, and my grumpiness will soon subside. RS 17 Jan: "common to a lot if not all of the aftermarket tops." To which I will and did add "as fitted" RL 17 Jan: "gap of about 1" ... It should be more like 1/4 to 1/2" PH 17 Jan: "...material is so insufficient that the gutter arches above the top of the drop glass..." As I later point out, this MIGHT be a shortage of material, but it usually IS NOT such. RL 17 Jan: The appearance of cars in reference materials is not a criterion for judgement, unless the pictures are of original factory installations. The fact that AC printed it does not make it correct. "In each case the gap is around 1". "One picture shows the gutter 'arching' as Paul said but I suggest that is to do with the hood frame and not the hood material." My point, exactly. PH 18 Jan: "...inclined to suspect a bad jig than some problem with the frame," Not in my experience. "... especially if the old top was a significantly better fit on the same frame." Possibly a valid point, although nobody mentioned this situation ..." The individual fitting of the new top can affect fit, but is not generally the cause of the arching over the windows. LH 18 Jan : true, but this should become apparent to a competent installer. JB 18 Jan: More on the first , later. "...never seen one that did seal well" See below. FRM 19 Jan Stands, but I realized is incomplete, hence my next post.. R Lloyd 19 Jan - Still puzzled! FRM 20 Jan: Stands, and note that I acknowledge one possible cause of "insufficient material" I will point out that my two posts to this point tell you nearly all you need to know to figure out how and why your top "doesn't" fit, and how to tell if it "will" fit, but you gotta think about it. PH 21 Jan: answered in my next. FRM 21 Jan: "...appear to be some tops with insufficient material width, I have found these to be either very old stock or very cheap tops, the latter not so much a problem as it used to be when there was a lot of low price competition" acknowledging the possibility raised by Paul, and giving my experience. I have not had a top in the last 15-20 years (or tops) that was of insufficient material width. There was a single top that MAY have been very slightly too narrow, but I also did not understand this as well as I do now. It was a take-apart frame believed to be from a "68, on a "73 that has had significant body work of dubious quality, and I found it necessary to trim the lugs which fit in the side sockets by 5/16 each side, to keep it from being too taut, and to correct the window fit. CF 26 Jan: YES, numerous if not most companies do so. JB 26 Jan: "..the fit is just fine," How does this match the above "....never seen one that did seal well" ? "...tend to agree " Thanks. PH 27 Jan: "No doubt expensive ones..." I have doubt, but then, I don't know about expensive ones, as I've never put one on. Perhaps those who install expensive ones are more careful - and charge more - than the guys who fit "cheap" ones. FRM 27 Jan: This stands as written. I am as stated disappointed and annoyed that nobody seems to get it, and, the discussion so far seems to not have helped anyone. Everybody seems to think that it is the top maker's fault, and there is no way to GET a top to fit, no way to tell IF a top will fit. I truly think most of you can do better. Thestatement: ***It ain't the top, it's the installation!*** is what is known as a rhetorical device, in the same vein as "If you kids don't sit down and listen, you get no dinner for a week" I would expect most adults to understand this. Withal, the statement is in my experience at least 98% true in the last twenty years. "lots of crappy parts out there" Yet another acknowledgement of Paul's possibilty of "bad" parts. RS 27 Jan: "...bought a lousy Chinese made part and it doesn't fit, it's your own damn fault" Maybe. If the part "WILL NOT" fit, and you can prove it, it"s the maker's fault. If you can't prove it, then we don't know. If it in fact "WILL" fit, but DOES not, then yes,. it's your - the installer's - fault. If it will not fit, and you fit it anyway, it's your fault that it is on the car, but explainable and perhaps understandable. JB 27Jan: I have not, and do not "...fitted every kind of top made and says they can all be made to fit correctly....", but I believe that I have used a pretty representative sample, as detailed. RS 28 Jan: "...sagging from age..." An MGB that is sagging with age is far beyond worry about tops. If the doors close, you can fit the top. The installed fit and correct matching of components IS the responsibilty of the installer "...simply crap" Yes there are many such parts, as acknowledged. And there is a lot of crap reading, writing, and thought, as you demonstrate. I'll put it down to a bad day, hope you get better soon. "...pass judgment on every single ill-fitting top..." Didn't do that - see "rhetorical device" above, grow up. "....have year after year after year of fitting top after top after top..." I wouldn't claim quite that, but I have a lot, as detailed. "We come here seeking advice, not scorn" I came here to give advice, not to get scorn, and I don't give scorn until you earn it - you are getting close. "If someone has advice, give it. " Did that "That's why most of come here: to ask questions and to learn" Learn? That takes some listening to the asked for advice, some work, some investigation. You show no sign of doing any of that. "If someone disagrees with somebody else's advice, say so and give reasons for that disagreement - preferably offering a viable alternative answer in the process." Well, I've been trying. You seem to disagree with me, so where's the "viable alternative"? "Don't blame people for being victims of others' failures" If you blame the top manufacturer for the failure of the installer, how does that help the guy with the leaky top? If you were the installer, then it's your fault. If you bought the job, go talk to the installer. "...do NOT heap scorn on ..." You don't deserve it, scorn is hard work. The advice is as good as I can make it, get off your duff and go study the car before you dismiss it. Got any valid questions, ask. Don't heap scorn on those who give of time and experience. Your comments are stupid and inflammatory, I hope you are better than they suggest. PH 28 Jan: "But if the old top fitted fine and the new one is rubbish..." As I observed, this did not seem to me to be the point of discussion. "...the force needed to pull the centre too far forwards such that it pulls the sides ..." It is not pulling the top forward that pulls the sides in, though some such slight effect could happen, but you'd likely never get the top up. My experience since I figured this out is that it is always a frame problem.. "...FRM can't accept that poor manufacture ..." I hope that it is clear by now that I never said such, except as a "rhetorical device". "There are certainly lots of crappy parts out there...." and I fear there will be many more. As far as I know, all tops I have experience with were UK or US made, but I expect this to deteriorate with time. CF 28 Jan: By now, you know what I will say. Frames get bent over time, One ill advised attempt to stuff the top down can do it. Such things as the notches being wrong are clearly manufacture troubles, and should be treated as such. To repeat: The point of all this is to fix the bad fitting tops, not to make anyone feel badly, or to start a fight. There is no point in expecting manufacturers to attend to things that are not their doing; the ones who care are already making tops that fit, and those who don't care won't care about your complaints either. The beauty of being the guy who screwed up is that you are also the guy who can fix it. With enough practice, you might even fix the last guy's goofs. To date, nobody has given any feedback to the effect that they have examined a car in response to any of this, with the notable exception of Jim B -many thanks, Jim. Nobody has asked anything sensible, nobody has emailed me, nobody has sent pictures. I am going to write this up with pictures, and I am going to offer it for sale. Unlike many here, this is supposed to be how I make my living - you expect to get paid when you go to work, I need that too. When finished, it will tell you what can go wrong and how to fix it, how to check before fitting, how to tell if a top WILL or won't fit before you install, what your chances are on an ill-fitting top already in place.. I have a 79 B here that could use some top refit, though I did much of it earlier. Since I have corrected or replaced the tops on most of the cars available to me, I need more victims. If you are "near", you can bring the car and I will fix it for a reasonable fee. 100mi Nof Pittsburgh, 50 S of Erie, 50 E of Ohio border. The first few people who send pictures to me that will show what is necessary, will get free analysis. This goes until I get all the info/pics needed. I'll even extend it to Mr Stevens. E-mail above, as always. FRM |
| FR Millmore |
| In answer to Carl's questions about whether anyone still makes a good fitting top. Working at Moss Motors and owning British cars does have it's advantages. My 70 MGB and 80 TR8 both have brand new Robbins tops on them following customer complaints of top fit. Robbins takes any complaint seriously and if necessary will organize getting a car in and pay to have a top fitted to ensure their patterns are correct. Keep in mind the top material has changed dramatically over the years and each time it changes the top patterns must be updated to ensure the stretch in each direction is correct. I remember when Robbins changed from Stayfast to Sun-Fast material and they made 4 or 5 tops before they were satisfied. The issue with Carl's Dad's top caused a lot of head scratching both at Moss and Robbins. Evidently the pattern for the top may never have been correct, but without an original frame to work with it was not possible to make a top that fit to satisfaction. The good thing about the experience was that Carl's dad was good enough to provide lots of photographs which allow us now to understand and identify this rare top bow set. This information should be on the web site and catalogs soon, so owners can determine which bow set they have. On the question of installation. I've done my own top installation and I've seen them done by professionals. It really does take a feel to understand how the material stretches, and I guess I don't have it. |
| KJ Dodd |
This thread was discussed between 17/01/2007 and 06/02/2007
MG MGB Technical index
This thread is from the archives. Join the live MG MGB Technical BBS now