Welcome to our Site for MG, Triumph and Austin-Healey Car Information.
MG MGB Technical - Distributor Install question
| I am installing a new 45D distributor in my '70GT.replacing the 25D that is there now. I had the rotor arm pointed toward #1 plug as reference. Installing the new 45D, one of the new Lucas ones that are common now. The only way it will drop in, the rotor arm is 180* out, Should I just leave it put the cap on and make the position on the cap that the rotor is pointing to #1 plug lead??? Is this thing assembled wrong? drive dog backwards? any comments? Mike |
| MK Mike |
| MK If you haven't turned your engine, the new distributor should show the same alignment as the one removed. Sounds like someone at Lucas installed the drive dog 180 out. You can correct yourself, but I would wonder what else might be wrong with this new unit. I would return for refund or replacement. What was wrong with your 25D unit? |
| Steve Buchina |
| Hi Steve Have not turned the motor but am not sure if it's at TDC but that should not matter. PO sawed off the vacume advance, I guess for the WeberDGV that's installed. But if I decide to stay with this just rotating the drive dog will do the trick? Mike |
| MK Mike |
| Mike. I am more familiar with the internals of the 25D than the 45D series, so my comments may not apply in your case. With the 25D distributors the hole for the cross pin holding the drive dog to the distributor shaft is off-set slightly. In other words, it only works one way on the shaft. It is, however, possible to use a large enough hammer to get the cross-pin most of the way into the drive dog and file off the excess. I have seen this on several "rebuilds". But, the answer to your question, "Can I turn the drive dog 180 deg" is probably no. You can, however mark the distributor shaft and the drive dog relationship with a dab of nail polish or paint and see if, on your distributor, it would be possible to rotate the drive dog 180 deg and reinstall the cross-pin without damage. If you decide to do this, do not force anything. I suspect that your new dizzy is correct and the orientation of the distributor drive gear in the engine is 180 out. You have to look very carefully at the workshop manual illustration to notice the proper offset. A lot of people, including me, have installed the drive gear 180 out over the years. I have always removed and replaced it in the correct orientation. Others simply swap the points can on their Lucas 25D4 distributors 180 degrees and start up the engine. The Lucas 25D4 distributor can have the points cam installed correctly or 180 out. If the distributor drive gear is installed 180 out, swapping the points cam 180 deg compensates for that and allows the distributor to look "normal" from the outside. This is, most probably, the situation you find yourself in and your new distributor is assembled correctly--highlighting the problem with the dizzy drive gear. Turning the points cam 180 degrees is easy on the 25D4 dizzy. I have not tried it with the 45D4, but Jeff S has more experience with them than I do. You might want to post a note to Jeff (Jeff S--I need your help) and refer him to this thread for his comments. I would swap the points cam 180 deg, if possible. Much easier than getting the distributor housing out of the block and pulling the drive gear. (The distributor housing is that oval shaped piece which has a tube attached, fitting into the block and into which the distributor fits. Its secondary purpose is to control movement of the dizzy drive gear away from the cam as a skew gear will tend to "walk" outward and disengage itself if not restrained. Hence, the distributor housing, held in place by one large screw, which is normally frozen and place and a bear to remove, is a more difficult fix, especially inside the car, than the distributor on the bench.) It would be interesting to hear what you find out and what others have to say. Les |
| Les Bengtson |
| Mike. Was thinking some more about this. The Weber DGV has a vacuum port near the bottom of the carb, being a brass nipple intended for ported vacuum take off. Do not remember if the 70 model year used a ported take off or a manifold take off. If manifold take off, the manifold needs to be drilled and tapped to take a hose barb to allow the use of the vacuum advance can. Les |
| Les Bengtson |
| "PO sawed off the vacume advance, I guess for the WeberDGV" This guy was a bit extreme. Wonder why, considering I see no purpose served. You might want to turn engine to TDC on compression stroke and check for proper dizzy alignment. I generally remove number 1 plug, insert index finger and turn engine until pressure is felt. Then, slowly continue turning engine until mark on crankshaft pulley aligns with main pointer (TDC) on timing chain cover. At this point, rotor should align with number one post of distributor cap. With tip (manifold port) of vacuum module (VM) pointing near 11 o'clock, she should start. If alignments seem off the mark, someone (PO) may have been playing with the distributor drive (e.g., removed and replaced a few teeth off). On your sawed off dizzy, where is the LT lead positioned? Could it be that the PO installed dizzy drive 180 out and sawed of VM for fit. |
| Steve Buchina |
| To get things right here I think you have to check and then possibly correct the drive gear alignment. Turn the crank to No1 TDC compression stroke and then ensure that the drive gear is inserted with the slot just below the horizontal i.e the large offset uppermost with the slot being at approx the two o'clock position. If this is not the case use a 5/16" x 3 1/2"long bolt and screwing this into the drive gear withdraw it. Then reinsert with the slot horizontal and as you insert it the slot should turn anticlockwise to the two o'clock position. Reinsert the distributor and set points staticaly rearranging the leads in the cap to suit this configuration. |
| Iain MacKintosh |
| Iain. While you state the common wisdom, most people do not mention, as I did, that the distributor housing must be removed before this can be accomplished. The distributor housing serves two functions--it sleeves the hole in the block down to the size of the distributor body's lower portion, and it holds the distributor drive into the engine. Without removing the distributor housing, it is impossible to remove the distributor drive. The housing is a tight fit into the block and is held in place by a single machine screw--one which is both awkward to get to when the engine is in the car and, frequently, frozen in place. I had to make a special "screwdriver" to remove and replace the screw without damage and get sufficient leverage to loosen the screw. This with the engine out. The housing must, frequently, be moved in a rotational manner before the bond between the housing and block releases sufficiently to allow it to be withdrawn, thus allowing the distributor drive shaft to be removed. Hence, one often finds that swapping the points cam 180 degrees, if possible, or installing the number one spark plug wire at the 7 O'clock position, the number three spark plug wire at the 4 O'clock position, the number four spark plug wire at the 2 O'clock position and the number two spark plug wire at the 11 O'clock position is a more viable method of correcting the problem. Les |
| Les Bengtson |
| MK Mike, As I read your post, you were asking if your new distributor was 180 degrees out. My answer was essentially - Yes, but only if your original dizzy was correct. It's possible, considering you VM was cut off, that you distributor drive is 180 degree off (or somewhere in between). Trying not to make things to uncomplicated, check the alignment of your 25D distributor with your engine at TDC on the compression stroke. Under these conditions, it is my experience and preference that: 1) the rotor button should point to the number one wire post (inside cap). Number one post is upper right on your distributor cap. Number three is upper left. Number four is lower left. Number two is lower right. 2) LT wire clip will be at (near) 3 o'clock. 3) Cap clips will be at (near) 12 and 6 o'clock. 4) Vacuum module port will point near 11 o'clock. If these positions are off, then your distributor drive was probably installed wrong. I've seen engines with the drive dog 180 degrees off, but also all positions in between. Most times it's not a big deal - just distributor orientation is off a bit (making vacuum tube attachment difficult) or plug wire insertions have to be changed. If the alignment of your old 25D is (or near) correct, your new dizzy was assembled wrong. You can either correct or replace. If your 25D doesn't align (near) to the positions outlined above, then your drive dog is off and corrections should be made. At 180 degrees off, the drive dog in your engine was installed wrong and your new dizzy is correct. |
| Steve Buchina |
| Thanks all. As Les has pointed out the EXTREME difficulty of removing the Dist Housing( I broke one trying to remove it from a parts engine that was out of the car) That is out of the question. Steve, you last post is pretty much the story. The old 25D lines up exactly as you describe so I guess the drive dog is out. Mailed the guy I got it from and he told me he has seen it on others he has sold.......So if I drift out the pin on the drive dog and turn it around that should work, will I be able to reuse the pin? and if I were to swap the points cam, how would I go about it? Does the part inside the cam, the part the rotor fits over, move?? or do you loosen the screw and hold the lower shaft and rotate it? Thanks for all the input. Mike |
| MK Mike |
| Oh yeah the new distributor with vacume cannister is needed because I will be changing back to twin SU's also... The vacume can on the 25D was plugged with epoxy/silicone that had a jagged look where the cannister end was so with my limited vision it looked sawed off to me when actually the vacume unit was just removed and plugged. Maybe I can possibly swap a good vac can to mine and right the drive dog on the 45D and keep it for another project. |
| MK Mike |
| MK Mike, Since the 45D is new, pin should come out without much effort (it can be reused). When I do this, I generally use a short piece of 2X4 with a hole in it for outer shaft support. Additionally, because the drive dog has a diameter slightly less than the main shaft, I place a thin holed washer under the drive dog an over the hole in the wood. With a drop of oil and a 3/16" drift, tap the pin out. An extra set of hands would help. Make sure you mark (or note) the shaft and drive dog alignments before you remove the pin. If you don't - you might put it back on wrong again. To double check, reference the orientation of your 25D distributor (i.e., holding distributor, with rotor button notch toward you, drive dog will be offset to the right of center). |
| Steve Buchina |
This thread was discussed between 24/01/2007 and 25/01/2007
MG MGB Technical index
This thread is from the archives. Join the live MG MGB Technical BBS now