Welcome to our Site for MG, Triumph and Austin-Healey Car Information.
MG MGF Technical - Body stiffening...
| Anyone had any thoughts about retro-fitting the TF stiffening rods to an F? From what I saw of the engine cover arrangement on the TF I would have thought only a little welding would be required (though access might be tricky). Don't know what they've done at the front. Just a thought... E |
| Ed Clarke |
| Ed i think someone (Andy/Scarlet) had already started talking about this, i think they mentioned that as you say a bracket would have to be welded on, however i was thinking whether a bracket could be fabricated that just bolted on? Also what are peoples thoughs on retro-fitting the X type bracing on the subframes, welding required, or just drill and bolt? I'm assuming the X bracing behind the dash would be too dificult, again welding required?, (this is the only bit of the new bracing i haven't seen), but could bolted brackets be made? |
| Paul |
| >>Anyone had any thoughts about retro-fitting the TF stiffening rods to an F? << Why ? Just trade the F for a new TF ... It's got to be a cheaper option in the long run. Steve |
| Steve |
| You are quite right Steve, but it may be a question of how far one wants to go, and how much one is prepared to spend. Retro-fitting the TF suspension system to the MGF is not really a practical proposition, although selective part swapping may be possible and may confer benefit to the F. Seeing as the front suspension system is practically identical to the MGF (damper mounts and springs excluded) I don't see why the whole front sub-frame couldn't be swapped. Maybe acquire one when someone rights-off their TF... shouldn't be too long before they start appearing in salvage yards! ;o) Similarly, those body strengthening bars could be obtained from the same source, and for a good deal less from MGR. It all depends on your priorities, and how the pros are countered by the cons. For some, the new TF is never going to be an option. |
| Rob Bell |
| Hi, <I don't see why the whole front sub-frame couldn't be swapped> Possibly because the top of the spring/damper coilovers pass through the body shell into the front bonnet area. I guess someone will do it one day but one is into the realms of is it worth it? I don't know about the rear sub-frame as it's difficult to see all the modifications made. I would think that it would be just as awkward. It might be better to buy a TF shell and suspension, put back the F lights, bumpers and boot lid, and somehow camouflage those horrible side vents! Regards, Kes. |
| Kes |
| >>Possibly because the top of the spring/damper coilovers pass through the body shell into the front bonnet area.<< True, although the MGF front dampers also pass through the body work into the front body/ underbonnet area, albeit in a different position (outboard and forward of the coil-overs found in the TF). Fact is, I do not know what other changes have been made to the front subframe, and whether it would be compatible with Hydragas: this requires more study methinks. The rear subframe is a complete non-starter I should think- simply too many changes. Kes, I agree with you regarding the aesthetic of the TF side vents... oddly proportioned :o/ |
| Rob Bell |
| Question, slightly off subject. Can anyone tell me what MGR actually mean by solidly mountes subframes. Is it just a matter of using steel bushes on the mounts or what? |
| Tony Smith |
| errr....*g*, anyone got any info or thoughts about the X bracing as per original questions? Steve, i always actually save up and buy my cars...daft i know, probably not many people do now, and not only do i really like my F (3 years and counting), i can't afford a TF..*s*. Maybe its me but i still think it'd be a lot cheaper to buy the X bracing and make a few brackets...(if possible) than buy a new car, might not make not a bit of difference to the car, call it a hobby...*g*. |
| Paul |
| Wow, just re-read my last post, that was pompous...*g*, sorry guys. Right, back to the X bracing... |
| Paul |
| From what i have seen (not very much!), the engine bay bracing converges on a mounting bracket welded to the firewall that separates the engine compartment from the boot - I am not sure where they mount at the other ends. Transferring the rods should be relatively straight forward, however welding in a new mounting bracket looks to be very awkward. A new design bracket that bolts through the firewall sounds like a good idea to me - it certainly makes the job a lot easier and starts to sound like a practical proposition. What i don't know is whether MGR have strengthened the firewall to take the bracing loads for the TF as the bracket is mounted in the middle of the wall at the top, where the bending moment is greatest. From a structural standpoint, the 2 worst possible places to apply a load are in the centre of a span (bending moment) and just off the supports (shear forces). Therefore given that they are mounted here i would be extremely surprised if this wall wasn't re-engineered to take the extra loads in the TF. So, now we are looking at stiffening the firewall as well, this is more important in an F as it lacks the other stiffening componentry of the TF, making the loads transmitted through the engine bay braces that much higher. It is still possibly an option however, strip out the boot carpet and weld a stiffening plate on the inside of the boot on the firewall, drill the mounting holes and fix the bracket on the engine side, sort out the mounting points at the other ends of the two braces and bolt into position. After all of this, it may be easier to re-design the braces so that they mount elsewhere... SF |
| Scarlet Fever |
| So you want stiffening braces? Why didn't you say so before;-) Mike. |
| mike |
| With regard to changing the suspension - one of the reasons that Hydrogas is being dropped is that Dunlop are stopping production of the units - so perhaps that means at some time in the future F/TF hybrids will become fairly common a bit like chrome/rubber bumper *B*s? Ted |
| Ted Newman |
| Andy/Scarlet...spoken like a man on a construction course...*s*. I'm not sure there would be much bending moment in the firewall. I think it would act more like a pin jointed truss and the tension in the firewall would just form two triangulated bracing sections with the body and each section of the transverse brace, but i may be wrong. Anybody had a look at how the X bracing on the subframes is fixed? |
| Paul |
| >>Maybe its me but i still think it'd be a lot cheaper to buy the X bracing and make a few brackets<< I'm sorry - I didn't mean to be dismissive of the idea. Some of my other posts indicate that I'm unhappy about my '97 VVC's body strength; I believe one of the best ways to fix the F's bodyshell problems is to seam-weld it, but this is only practical if the bodyshell is rebuilt. MG have added the bracing struts as part of a package, which also includes changing the side panels to aid longitudinal stiffness - a problem on my car. I understand that the TF is not an option (it's not an option for me...) Steve |
| Steve |
| Two rigid ends connected by a flexible bit in the middle still equals a flexible body. MGR press releases seem to make a lot more of the mono-side body construction of the TF, claiming that this modification to the body construction alone is responsible for the majority of the 20% increase in torsional stiffness of the new car. Interestingly, the MGF cup car had cross braces welded into the engine bay from day one- but to make full advantage of this bracing, the car's body work was completely seam welded. Therefore I'd probably agree with what Steve has suggested. We'd probably only have a modest gain in stiffness with the cross braces, and these may not impact significantly on torsional stiffness... Which isn't to say that it isn't worth trying, just to see what would happen if one were to install a brace or two to an F... |
| Rob Bell |
| Paul, LOL, not only like a person on a construction course, but also like a person who spent 6½ years designing pre-cast concrete beams! :-) Your point about a pin joint is a valid one, it certainly could be designed that way, this is something i hadn't considered, and to be honest, in 3 dimensions is a bit beyond my experience. Mike, Glad to hear that you are volunteering, put me down for a set of engine bay braces... :-) SF |
| SF |
| Andy, OK, how about a concrete stiffening brace right down the middle :-). Any answer to my solid subframe mount question? To be honest all I really want on my F is independant hydragas and maybe lowering knuckles. I have wondered if seam welding the body joints that are easy to get at would improve things. To be honest I still think the Hydragas suspension can be very good if it is set up properly. I know it is not so easy as you really need to understand the loads and stresses. To seam weld one joint that is easy to get at may in turn put extra stress on another joint creating an even bigger problem. If you have Hydragas I think the only thing to do is to improve what you have rather than trying to change it to something else. MGR have the advantage of having all the figures so for them it is much easier to make modifications. I think the main advantage of the new setup is that Rover dealers will actually understand how it works. This IMO will mean a drop in revenue for the dealers who have used Hydragas as an excuse to rip off customers? I think if I ever get to earn a living again I'm going down to a scrap yard to collect a few spare Hydragas units for the future. This may mean that Hydragas units will be harder to come by in the future so we may all have to look at some kind of replacement to the Hydragas units anyway. Any suggestions from MGR? In the MG World test I saw that a comment was made about the car being more stable at speed, this was put down to the changes to the body, to be nonest I think this is also down to two other main factors, 1. The front wheels are now set toe in. Changing the suspension gave MGR to perfect chance to correct the settings without losing face. 2. The fact that with the new setup we have no front to back suspension connection thus ending the tendency for a standing wave being set up front to back on uneven road surfaces. Anyway I don't want a TF, I really don't like the look of it. Maybe this will change when I see one in the flesh, I was not too impressed with the look of the F from the photo's. I had to see a real car before I could tell if I liked it or not. Just because it is new does not mean everyone has to change to the new system, the MGF suspension is still great if set up properly and kept out of the hands of dealers. As for the stiffening bars I see no reason why Mike Satur can't add to his shock mount strengthening some form of bracing or at least a bracket to mount some stiffening bars directly. |
| Tony Smith |
| >>To be honest I still think the Hydragas suspension can be very good if it is set up properly. <snip>. To seam weld one joint that is easy to get at may in turn put extra stress on another joint creating an even bigger problem.<< My thoughts exactly >>Anyway I don't want a TF, I really don't like the look of it. Maybe this will change when I see one in the flesh, ...<< I thought so too - until I saw one. The price is about right at the moment too, and the TF160 is VED band C. All in all, the TF looks a good deal. Steve |
| Steve |
| Also if I had two Euro cents to rub together maybe that would also change my perspective :-) |
| Tony Smith |
| >>Any answer to my solid subframe mount question?<< Hi Tony, First, was that your letter I saw in MG World this month? Second, the solid mounts. Yes, they are as you summise: solid alloy spacers that replace the standard rubber items. These are fitted as standard to the MGF Trophy, and are available from the parts counter at your local MG dealer (assuming that the hand over of parts supply goes through soon!!!) Regarding TF tracking, the front is now parallel (0 degrees) and the rear is now 15 (!) degrees toe-in. The different rear toe-angle probably has everything to do with the altered rear geometry, and therefore not applicable to the MGF. Would be nice to see what bump-steer characteristics have been built in now... :o) |
| Rob Bell |
| >>and the rear is now 15 (!) degrees toe-in<< Surely not 15 DEGREES ? I've seen some women attempting to walk with that sort of toe-in, but I don't think a car would even move :-) Steve |
| Steve |
| <chuckle> no, not 15 degrees! That'd certainly result in some rather marked tyre wear!!! LOL 0 degrees, 15 minutes, Toe-IN. |
| Rob Bell |
| Tony, you are right, the shock mount brackets have a hole specially for the addition of a rear strut brace. Mike. |
| mike |
| I have seen all of three braces and positions that they fit. Remmebr too that a large proportion of the extra stiffening comes from the alteration of the rear wings and the sills to form the new 'monoside'. Additionally the mounting of the subframes soldily, they are the same mountings as you have on cars now but there is no rubber medium in them so they bolt metal to metal adds to the overall rigidity. Also remember that what has been done has been done to achieve the goals set for the minimum cost, ease of reproducing in thousands and has as little weight penalty as possible. Against this background the prospect of stitch welding the shell, (you need to retain some degree of shell movement) and certainly the addition of a roll cage would far exceed the stiffness achieved with the TF. Rog |
| Roger Parker |
| have some pictures of the additional bracing if anyone interested(Dieter;-)) Mike |
| mike |
| As far as the engine-bay braces are concerned, here are some photos that seem to show it's a simple bolt-on affair http://www.btinternet.com/~edward.clarke/Luton/LutonMeet.html Also some shots of underneath front sub-frame of both TF and F, with the new cross-braces visible (just). Not so straight forward ... E |
| Ed Clarke |
This thread was discussed between 14/03/2002 and 27/03/2002
MG MGF Technical index
This thread is from the archives. Join the live MG MGF Technical BBS now