MG-Cars.info

Welcome to our Site for MG, Triumph and Austin-Healey Car Information.

Recommendations

Parts

MG parts spares and accessories are available for MG T Series (TA, MG TB, MG TC, MG TD, MG TF), Magnette, MGA, Twin cam, MGB, MGBGT, MGC, MGC GT, MG Midget, Sprite and other MG models from British car spares company LBCarCo.

MG MGF Technical - do coolant pipes corrode from the inside out? or outside in?

i was thinking of putting some silver smoothrite on my coolant pipe to stop corrosion, would this do any good, or do they rot from the inside out?
richb

My guess is they won't rust from the inside if you use the correct coolant containing corrosion prohibitor.

Russ
Russell Morgan

Good question Rich. I was looking at the same pipes recently and they are corroded around the welded joints for the mountings and at various other points too, maybe from stone chips. I was going to treat the rusty areas with Kurust and then top coat those areas with black high temperature paint i got from Halfords. I spoke to Mike Satur about this in passing and he was very sceptical that the corrosion could be stemmed and of course recommended his aluminium replacement pipes. If these didn't require draining down the whole system i would have gone for them. I tried to get my dealer to fit them at my last service when they changed the coolant but unfortunately they wouldn't fit Mike's stuff.

Last year I had a small leak from the joint between one of the metal coolant pipes and the connecting flexible rubber pipe just in front of the engine. The dealer initially suspected corrosion tracking down the metal pipe inside the connection to the rubber pipe. He pulled back the rubber pipe at the joint but the metal pipe was fine underneath. Next the Rover spring type clip was changed for a Mike Satur hose clip (by me), still continued to leak. In the end it was diagnosed as a deterioration in the actual rubber of the flexible pipe which meant that a good seal could not be achieved. Ironically the rubber had gone very soft and too flexible, it could be easily compared with the firmer ok rubber pipe alongside it for the second coolant run. New rubber pipe and Rover clip later and it has been fine since. Moral of this is perhaps we should be more concerned about the state of the flexible pipes than the rigid pipes!
Paul

I dont know why your dealer wouldnt fit the pipes.
i had mine fitted at a dealers on the 5th year service it wasnt my local dealer, but they said they wuld fit them but not guarantee them....

worth doing at the service if they will.
try http://www.richardsons-group.com/tivertonpage.html

this was where i got mine done, a 200 mile round trip but worth it for the service.. i ad the HG change at the same time..
Nick Walters

According to my dealer my coolant pipes corroded from the inside out. The cockpit filled with steam, which was fun as I was doing 70ish at the time.

I believe that Rover changed the design of the pipes to reduce internal corrosion. No doubt Dieter can give you the VIN number at which the changed happened ;)

Ralph
Ralph

Ralph interested to hear that your dealer told you they rusted from inside out, i hope you got them changed under the 5 year anti-corrosion warranty if that was the case. I am puzzled though as you'd think many other metal things in contact with the coolant would also rust from the inside out. How old was your car or how long was it since you had your coolant changed and if it was changed, did the dealer change it. I wonder about the anti-corrosion properties of your coolant. Lets say i'm sceptical. Anyway, the pipes on my car are definatetly rusting from the outside in.
Paul

Just re read Ralphs and my last post, question: would failure of the pipes underneath the car cause the car to fill with steam? Were these pipes actually in the car?
Paul


Hi all,

with the battery ground point at the front and the generator groundpoint at the rear with the chassie as only total groundreturn (voltage drop with driving lights on 0,85 V ) they HAVE to corrode, inside OR outside !
Possibly rectification is a battery ground return by a thick insulated cable to a good groundpoint at the rear! Too late to do this season but probably a job for the comming winter....

Regards , Carl.
Carl

Yes Carl is of course right, they corrode both internally and externally, unlike aluminium!!I do guarantee them and would not expect a third party fitting them to offer any warranty on the actual part.
Paul, strange your Rover dealer didn't want to use one of my parts, I use Rover stuff all the time ;-). maybe they know you will be back!!
Mike.
mike

As Nick Walters found out, I wouldn't have any problem fitting Mike's alloy pipes to any MGF!

If the MGR parts can only last 4/5 yrs (on the outside...) then the alloy pipes are a godsend IMHO!
Dave

This thread was discussed between 14/03/2002 and 16/03/2002

MG MGF Technical index

This thread is from the archives. Join the live MG MGF Technical BBS now