Welcome to our Site for MG, Triumph and Austin-Healey Car Information.
MG MGF Technical - HGF Again ?? Say it isn't so.
| This morning on the way to work my temperature gauge shot straight into the red zone after about 1 mile. Pulled the car in. No steam coming out the back, coolant level looks ok, no gunk on the dipstick. Let the car rest for 15 minutes, turn on the ignition (without starting the car), temp gauge rises straight to the top. Heater is on One, at about halfway between cold and hot. Gauge is moving / twitching slightly up, slightly down. Turn on the fans full blast on the hottest temp, ice cold air is coming out despite the temp guage being at the top. However, I now note that with the heaters fully open the temp gauge is going back down to one below halfway (normal position), so I try to drive off the main road I am on with heaters on full, cold air turns very warm within a minute (heaters on 4, fully opened), manage to find a safe spot to pull in just as temp tops out again, shut the car off. Check the fluids, oil, no anomolies, no leaks. I have driven the car 100 miles since the clutch was replaced. Someone please tell me that this is something simple. |
| Dave Quigley |
| Sounds more like a temp sender problem - 1 mile should barely be enough to warm the engine up, let alone over-heat, even if you had the dreaded HGF. E |
| Ed Clarke |
| make that temp sensor, but I have to say they this is unlightly to be the problem on such a short run and it is more lightly to be the water pump (if temp in the car is intermittant(hot/cold not hot/roasting) or missing ) or the thermostat- but if it was the thermostat i would expect it to take longer. My friend had the water pump go in a metro- but the garage couldn't find the problem because when all was cold the pump behaved correctly, it was only when it got hot and the metal expanded that the rotor got loose. Wil |
| Will Munns |
| Dave, I have to say that this does not *sound* like a HGF. You've made some interesting observations: the engine apparently running very hot, whilst the heater was initially blowing cold being an important one. The engine has two temperature sensors: one that supplies the ECU and another that supplies the temperature guage. They are coloured brown and blue, respectively. It is possible that one or other of these are faulty, or have a dirty connection with the wiring loom. They are reasonably easy to get to (see the instructions on sensor replacement on http://www.mgf.4mg.com/hgf_diagnosis.htm - the ECU temp sensor is shown- the blue guage sensor is below it in the vertical plane). One problem with this theory is that when sensors fail, or if there is a poor electrical connection with it, the electrical resistance increases. This usually means that the sensors are reading falsely 'cool' (the sensor resistance drops with increasing temperature). When this occurs with the ECU sensor, the coolant overheats- as seen on the temperature guage; however, this problem usually is not manefest until you are sitting in slow moving traffic. On the move, there is sufficient air movement through the radiator to cool the engine without the need for the MEMS to switch on the radiator fan- the non-function of which is the cause of the overheating. A problem with the faulty temp-guage sensor theory is that you would expect the temp guage to show the opposite to what you are seeing: the engine apparently running cold. So I suspect that this is not your problem. So really the question is- is the coolant *really* that hot? One way to look at this is to swop the connectors to the two sensors to see if the guage continues to read hot. If this is the case, then the question is *why* is the coolant hot. A thermostat failure is a possibility- it'd certainly explain a hot engine with a cold heater, but the fact that the heater later warms up would suggest at least partial opening of the thermostat. I guess the question is "is it enough"? Certainly an avenue for further investigation. Water pump failure is rare, but does happen. Those of you who remember the problems that Annalise had with her car will recall that the cam belt failure occured secondarily to a failure of the water pump. If you are seriously considering pump failure as an option, then drive the car no further. Get it trailed or towed to a garage for further investigation: running the car further just isn't worth the risk. However, you'd expect other 'symptoms' such as noise etc that would be tell-tale of impending destruction... But again an imporant avenue of investigation. I hope that the problem turns out to be something simple Dave- and do keep us all posted. |
| Rob Bell |
| Sorry Rob, >A thermostat failure is a possibility- it'd certainly explain a hot engine with a cold heater The heater is on a tight loop without a thermostat, the thermostat only controls the flow of water to the radiator - so the heater should vary from hot to very hot as the engine temp exceeds the normal. If the heater varies from cold to very hot the I suspect that only a failed water pump or air lock is possible. Have you released pressure from the system by opening the cap with the car still warm- or had any service done recently? Water pump failure is not that unusual - I had it on the 214, but the problem with mine caused loss of coolant, my friend had his go on the metro with simmiler issues as Dave |
| Will Munns |
| Ah, yes, you are right Will. For some reason I was thinking that the heater circuit was guarded by the thermostat- D'oh! No it's not. The thermostat regulates the flow of water from the radiator on the return side only. |
| Rob Bell |
| More info. I think that even though the temp was in the red zone, the engine bay fan was not coming on. I could be wrong, but I am pretty sure I didn't hear it. The one mile bit is misleading as this was in traffic, I suppose I was on the go about 10-13 mins. I am a little worried that fully opening the heater valve brought the temp back down (for a couple of minutes). The car has recently been in for a new clutch (in fact it was 5 months off the road as a result). This would have involved moving the engine out etc... Since I got it back the car has gone about 100 miles only. I can't believe my luck. Last 2 problems I had, both turned out to be worst case scenario, 4 figure repair bills, I must be due a break. I think the wise move now would be to patch it up and lose it before it destroys me. Maybe get one of the newer ones. |
| Dave Quigley |
| Does the temperature drop when on the open road, away from traffic? You need a forward speed of about 40-50 mph to get really good radiator cooling in the absence of the radiator fan... In this case, we *could* be looking at an ECU temp sensor failure, which fortunately costs a one-figure sum to fix... Part number details on the aforementioned web page. |
| Rob Bell |
| OK sounding more like a temp sensor fault now! that or a fault with the thermostat. If the coolent is not circulating then it gets hot and the water gauge will go up- the engine may sill be quite cool and the engine bay cooler still- so the engine bay fan should not be on. The radiator fan however should be- if the radiator fan was spinning then it's not a temp sensor problem- if it wasn't then it is! If the heater is working normally (or a bit hotter ;-) then it is not a water pump problem. Which leaves a sticky thermostat or an air lock. so if you have been driving it normally (or in the same conditions) in the last 100 miles, and you havent opened the expansion cap when the system is warm(causes hiss) when it is not an air lock. So I put my money on the thermostat |
| Will Munns |
| Rob, after the temp went back down (and subsequesntly back up, I was in a residental area at 20-30mph tops, I crawled into work just as the temp was hitting the red. Hated driving it those last couple of hundred meters, but had no choice, If I had left the car in the area the problem occured, it would probably be burnt out by now. Will, I haven't opened the expansion cap at all since I got it back. Was tempted to this morning to see if the coolant was hot though. I'm going to try confirm the engine bay fan wasn't on, pretty sure it wasn't though as if it was, it's difficult not to hear it. (Very loud in my car). |
| Dave Quigley |
| As said, it's not the engine bay fan, but the radiator fan (at the front of the car) which you should be interested in. Will |
| Will Munns |
| ... and the rad fan is really difficult to hear. You have to be standing in front of the car for it to be audible. Obviously not very practical if you happen to be driving at the time... ;o) It's a good test: start the car from cold, and let it idle. Depending on the ambient temperature, the radiator fan should kick in between 5 to 10 minutes after starting. No fan, then suspect the ECU temperature sensor. It does not cost much, so is worth replacing (10 quid) irrespective of whether the connections are the cause. Then repeat test. Rad fan should now work, and overheating problem solved. |
| Rob Bell |
Hi Dave, really sorry to hear about Your problem! Canīt recall if You have mentioned DIY-activity in any thread before but I think it is pretty safe for anyone with some knowledge to at least bleed the heater nipple. This can be done with almost any tool at hand ,(pliers,block or ring key or even a crude spanner). The main thing is to lift out the black plastic shroud under the front bonnet that covers it. See Dieters Tech site or maybee this is covered on Robīs site as well. IMO anyway a good chance to get rid of some trapped air in order to be able to get to a good garage for further pressure test etc. If air comes out the expansion bottle will empty so be sure to fill up again ,tap water will do. best of luck, Carl. |
| Carl |
| Dave, Sounds like air in the cooling system. Water hot, no heat from the heater. Poor water circulation, and your engine overheating. Bleed the system before you drive it again. This is a perfect recipe for HGF. You will probably find a coolant leak too if you look. The temperature sensors will not read hot when they're sensing air temperature. But the sensor in the overheated water will sense hot. Word of warning.......If your engine is hot, and there's no heat from the heater, you have air in your cooling system IMO |
| george |
| Screams air lock to me also. Rog |
| Roger Parker |
| Yes, however, one final spanner in the works. When it was being towed away yesterday, my mechanic, came along and ran the engine until it started to get hot, at this point the expansion cap was off and he hand his hands around the bottle. The temp reading was in the red zone, the bottle was only warm, the coolant was bubbling and boiling, the engine itself felt cold, the water pipes up front next to the radiator were cold as ice, which I immediately thought meant they were blocked but he gave them a squeeze and water started swirling about a bit in the expansion tank so certainly it seemed that the car wasn't overheating despite what the readings said. So we drove it a couple of hundred metres at this stage very hot air was coming out the heaters (no hotter than usual though), turned it off and decided to tow it away as a precaution. Note with the engine turned off, ice cold air was coming from the radiators within a minute or two, however the temp gauge stayed on full for a further 10 minutes before slowly creeping back down again. What does this mean ? If it is an air pocket then I need to get as much info as possible as the mechanic would have had to move the engine to replace the clutch, which means that the system would have had to be bled. I have only gone about 100 miles since this work. |
| Dave Quigley |
| If the engine is off then the water pump can not push the water round the engine/heater circuits- so the effect is that the heater (which you are cooling) gets cold, but the water which is hot and still in the engine stays hot and still in the engine. Will |
| Will Munns |
This thread was discussed between 13/03/2002 and 14/03/2002
MG MGF Technical index
This thread is from the archives. Join the live MG MGF Technical BBS now