MG-Cars.info

Welcome to our Site for MG, Triumph and Austin-Healey Car Information.

Recommendations

Parts

MG parts spares and accessories are available for MG T Series (TA, MG TB, MG TC, MG TD, MG TF), Magnette, MGA, Twin cam, MGB, MGBGT, MGC, MGC GT, MG Midget, Sprite and other MG models from British car spares company LBCarCo.

MG MGF Technical - Replacement Speakers

I've installed a mk2 T-bar cover and the associated speakers in my F in an attempt to improve the sound quality. Whilst happy that there is some improvement over just the standard front speakers I reckon that the Clarion CD-Player I fitted could sound better if I replaced the standard speakers. This raises the following questions :
(1) Has anyonre replaced the mk2 speakers whilst keeping the current mounting boxes ? if so what with ?
(2) Can I remove the front speaker grilles without taking the whole door panel off ?
(3) What size speakers do I need for the front ?
(4) Ive seen some component speakers by Magnat for £50. Has anyone got any experience of their speakers ?? Are they a good brand or not ?
M Turner

I can't help you with all the questions- I'll leave that to our resident ICE experts.

However, I can confirm that the door cards DO need to be removed to get at either the speakers or the speaker trims. The speaker trims are simple plastic mouldings covered in fabric. There are four plastic pins through the card; their ends are melted and squahed flat to create a lip that holds the pins and therefore the trims in place. I removed the standard speaker grilles by drilling out the pins and replaced the grilles with alloy items found in the Rover BRM. This simple change made an astonishing difference to the sound quality! :o) Much clearer now... Unfortunately, my wallet is also considerably lighter too :o/

Speaker options are many and numerous. Not heard of Magnat. Many have recommended the Infinity Kappa range of components. Check the archive for more details. I seem to recall that Gaz fitted Infinitis into the T-bar of his car- but I'm not sure whether he used a MY2000 T-bar or not...
Rob Bell

Rob,

Have you got pictures of your BRM Speaker covers?
I have fitted a set of infinity speakers 652i's, sounds great but the speaker grills aren't the best.

So i am searching for ideas.

Paul
paul weatherill

Hi Paul,

I'm very pleased with the look of the BRM grilles- some pictures of them in the door can be seen incidently amongst these images of how to remove the door card: http://www.mgf.4mg.com/door_panel_removal.htm

Details, part numbers and costs of those BRM speaker grilles (Rover parts dept prices, no idea if anyone else can get them cheaper? Maybe from a scrapped car, but they are rare): http://www.mgf.4mg.com/BRM_Speaker_grilles.htm

Personally, I think they'd work very well in a MY2000 black/brushed alloy interior- the tweeter grilles could simply be relocated from the handle trim to the door...

I can't decide whether to fit a MY2000 interior to my car or not. Main concern at the moment is whether the MY2000 seaat squab may be set a little higher than the Mk1 seat. I'd like to 'try before I buy' - anyone performed this? (I know that John did, but bambino forced him to sell his car :o( )
Rob Bell

They look bloody nice, Rob. Hmm....
David Bainbridge

Paul where the Infinity speakers easy to fit ? Was it just a direct swap for the originals ? Did you need to fit the infinity grillesor could you have retained the original speaker grilles ? I'm keen to keep the interior looking as standard as possible.
M Turner

The original speakers are mounted into a plastic pod, a splash shield. These 'pods' can be re-used for any similarly sized speaker (16.5 cm diameter).

I've fitted Kenwood 2-way ceramic speakers (part number as per FAQ). I removed the original speakers from the plastic pods- they were held in place by bent metal tabs. I then drilled four mounting holes into the pods and fixed the new speakers into the pods, using the self-tapping screws supplied with the speakers.

I see no reason as to why this procedure should not be used for any speaker you happen to choose.

Some, such as ICE professionals like Sarah in Bristol (worth searching the archive using her name and addy for more ICE tips) make up their own speaker mounts using water-proofed MDF. The advantage is increased rigidity of the mount.

Not sure whether this is strictly necessary or not? Up to you.

>>They look bloody nice, Rob. Hmm.... <<

David- they are luuverly! Beautifully made as well. I should have known that you'd like 'em too! LOL
Rob Bell

Almost right Rob ... I fitted JBL 4" Power Series into cutouts on my MKI T-Bar. My advice is try Infinity's in the T-Bar. I have the 652i's in the front. I wasn't too impressed with either the OEM cloth grilles or the Infinity grills. You could try fitting the MKII grills or as I have done pick up a pair of black metal grills from Maplin (stores nationwide). I choose the Maplins because the holes are quite large (similar to the MS Windstop grill layout) thus allowing more sound thru. I hooked the rears up using hi-fi speaker cable ... QED original.

Gaz
Gaz

I tried Kenwoods 16.5cm speakers first - cost around £55 - They were no better than the OEMs - In fact the OEMS sounded better

Then Pioneers again £58 at halfords - still not good


Decided to splash out and buy some MB QUART components speakers online - around £100 the set - AWESOME !

Now fitted an Amp £130.00 -- all above speakers need POWER to run a decent signal to them OR they may sound worse

I too have a high power clarion - but it doesnt have the output to produce a good sound - High power states 45 watts per channel - equals about 15watts rms (actual) whci is no where near enough to run the or Quarts!

So my advice spend £250 get the MB QUARTS and a reasonable amp if you want GOOD sounds!

I may upgrade the Amp again soon as the speakers still require more power - But I can hear the sound clearly with reasonale tone and bass at 80mph + top down

Amp wise Kenwood Sony or Pioneer seem best money - but note THD values before actual output as its no good having a 100 watts per channel amp RMS if it distorts at 10% volume !!!

The Magnats I wouldnt touch!

All this is now in an MX5 but there will be little difference between that and the F !

Also may be worth paying for the install - Its a pain rewiring the doors for the additional tweeter on components speakers - but in my opinion well worth the extra money !
tony

I agree with you Tony, those Kendwoods aren't what they are cracked up to be (either that, or the OE speakers are surprisingly good!). I've heard nothing but good things about the Infinitis however. An amp is probably a good idea with these speakers too- although, I think I'm right in saying that Gaz's are powered by the head unit? (Oops- I thought you have Infinitis in the T-bar too, oh well, close, but no cigar! ;o)

Potentially of interest, I found that the Kenwoods sounded a whole load better for fitting sound proofing in the doors... (I used 'Brown Bread' for this)

More information on replacing the OE speakers to be found on Richard Eaton's web page: http://www.mgfworld.co.uk/windowstop.htm#speaker

And more still, with some images provided from Sarah Frazer on installing sound proofing on Greg Hilton's MGF FAQ: http://gregh.co.uk/html/mgfaq.htm#cd
Rob Bell

This thread was discussed between 13/03/2002 and 14/03/2002

MG MGF Technical index

This thread is from the archives. Join the live MG MGF Technical BBS now